Volvo Xc40 vs Bmw X1: Which is Better? (2026)
Side-by-side comparison of the Volvo Xc40 and Bmw X1, covering MOT pass rates, running costs, common faults, and overall reliability. Based on 301,315 real MOT tests.
Quick Verdict
This is a very close comparison. The Volvo Xc40 (93% pass rate) and Bmw X1 (88% pass rate) are evenly matched on reliability. Your decision should come down to personal preference, running costs, and which feels better to drive. Both are solid choices in the premium segment.
Volvo Xc40
93%
MOT pass rate
100,928 tests
More reliableBmw X1
88%
MOT pass rate
200,387 tests
Full Comparison: Volvo Xc40 vs Bmw X1
| Category | Volvo Xc40 | Bmw X1 |
|---|---|---|
| MOT Pass Rate | 93%Winner | 88% |
| MOT Fail Rate | 7%Winner | 12% |
| vs National Avg | +11 ptsWinner | +6 pts |
| Est. Fuel Cost (8,000 mi/yr) | £1,434 | £1,434 |
| Insurance Group | 18-28 | 25-35 |
| Est. Depreciation/yr | £1,200-£2,200 | £2,000-£3,500 |
| Engine Size | 1.8L | 2.0L |
| Fuel Type(s) | Petrol, Hybrid | Petrol, Diesel |
| Segment | Premium | Premium |
| Avg Mileage | 34,344 miWinner | 68,415 mi |
| MOT Tests Analysed | 100,928 | 200,387 |
| Model Years | 5 years | 14 years |
| Best Year | 2022 (96%)Winner | 2022 (94%) |
| Worst Year | 2018 (91%)Winner | 2009 (81%) |
| Reliability Trend | Stable | ImprovingWinner |
Common Problems Comparison
Volvo Xc40 Known Issues
- •Suspension wear on older models
- •Lighting defects (common on all cars)
Bmw X1 Known Issues
- •DPF and emissions issues (diesel models)
- •Higher tyre and brake wear (larger engine)
- •Suspension wear on older models
- •Lighting defects (common on all cars)
Check a Specific Volvo Xc40
Enter a reg plate to see the exact MOT history and running costs for a specific Volvo Xc40.
Check a Specific Bmw X1
Enter a reg plate to see the exact MOT history and running costs for a specific Bmw X1.
Save Money on Your Volvo Xc40
Exclusive deals and services picked for your Volvo Xc40
Compare car insurance
Could save you £200+ on insurance
Get quotes from top UK insurers in minutes
Compare quotes →Compare prices in 60 seconds
🚗Breakdown cover
Cover from under £4/month
RAC, AA, and Green Flag deals compared
Compare cover →Instant online quotes
✅Extended warranty
Plans from £15/month
Protect against unexpected repair bills
Get a quote →Cover starts immediately
🔧Book an MOT
Save up to 50% vs dealerships
Find the cheapest MOT near you
Find garages →Book online in minutes
Volvo Xc40 vs Bmw X1 FAQ
Which is more reliable, the Volvo Xc40 or Bmw X1?
Based on MOT data, the Volvo Xc40 is more reliable with a 93% pass rate, compared to 88% for the Bmw X1.
Which is cheaper to run?
At 8,000 miles per year, the Volvo Xc40 costs around £1,434 in fuel, while the Bmw X1 costs around £1,434. The Volvo Xc40 is cheaper on fuel. Insurance, depreciation, and repair costs also factor into total running costs.
Should I buy a Volvo Xc40 or Bmw X1?
This is a very close comparison. The Volvo Xc40 (93% pass rate) and Bmw X1 (88% pass rate) are evenly matched on reliability. Your decision should come down to personal preference, running costs, and which feels better to drive. Both are solid choices in the premium segment.
Volvo Xc40 Running Costs
Full breakdown of annual costs, reliability, and MOT data
Bmw X1 Running Costs
Full breakdown of annual costs, reliability, and MOT data
Compare Different Cars
Want to compare different cars? Enter any two reg plates for a personalised side-by-side comparison.
Compare Any Two Cars