CarCostCheck

BMW 5 SERIES (2009)

Running costs, common problems, and reliability data based on 1,296 real MOT tests in 2024.

Share:XFacebookWhatsApp

MOT Pass Rate

83%

Total Tests (2024)

1,296

Avg Mileage

149,453 mi

Est. Annual Cost

£1,900

Is the 2009 BMW 5 SERIES reliable?

Good reliability. Occasional issues but generally solid. That's close to the national average of 82%. It falls below the BMW brand average of 88%.

At 15 years old, 83% of BMW 5 SERIESs from 2009 passed their MOT first time in 2024. That's based on 1,296 tests across the UK. The average mileage at this age is 149,453 miles.

How does the 2009 BMW 5 SERIES compare?

Rank among all 2009 cars157th out of 575(top 27%)
Rank among all BMW models1223th out of 1,564(top 78%)
vs national average+1% (82% avg)
vs 2009 cars average+8% (75% avg)
vs BMW average-5% (88% avg)

Mileage Analysis

The average 2009 BMW 5 SERIES has 149,453 miles on the clock, which is above the expected 111,000 miles for a 15-year-old car. Higher-mileage cars often have more motorway miles, which is generally less harmful than stop-start urban driving.

Best year to buy a BMW 5 SERIES?

The most reliable year is the 2023 model with a 98% MOT pass rate, while the 1999 model has the lowest at 71%. The 2009 sits between the two at 83%.

How much does a 2009 BMW 5 SERIES cost to run?

⛽Fuel (Diesel, 2993cc)
£1,245
🏛️Road Tax
£250
🔧MOT Test
£55
🛠️Predicted Repairs
£350
Total per year£1,900
Per month£158/mo

Based on 7,400 miles/year (UK average), current fuel prices, and repair likelihood from MOT pass rate data. Insurance not included.

BMW 5 SERIES by Year

YearPass RateTestsAvg Mileage
202398%18524,552 mi
202296%58633,834 mi
202193%4,08135,046 mi
202092%9,40940,517 mi
201992%33,76652,218 mi
201891%40,27263,822 mi
201790%28,88473,845 mi
201691%10458,170 mi
201593%13577,391 mi
201488%49596,084 mi
201383%12,106116,962 mi
201283%12,364124,375 mi
201183%2,348129,743 mi
201083%1,299135,211 mi
200983%1,296149,453 mi
200883%1,682154,421 mi
200781%1,827159,927 mi
200680%1,465158,383 mi
200576%866156,443 mi
200478%555149,786 mi
200377%437139,654 mi
200278%330147,542 mi
200181%217138,008 mi
200075%179151,070 mi
199971%224143,099 mi
199880%184126,519 mi
199779%94129,696 mi
199678%55148,837 mi
199577%60147,066 mi
199484%51134,866 mi

Checking a specific BMW 5 SERIES?

Enter the reg plate to see its individual MOT history, mileage verification, and predicted costs.

GB

Free instant check using official DVSA and DVLA data

About the 2009 BMW 5 SERIES

The 2009 BMW 5 SERIES is a premium performance with a 2993cc diesel engine. 1,296 of these vehicles were MOT tested in 2024, making it a reasonably common sight on UK roads. Among all cars from 2009, the average MOT pass rate is 75%, and this model beats that benchmark.

With an average of 149,453 miles at 15 years old, BMW 5 SERIES owners cover more miles than the average driver.

2009 BMW 5 SERIES Fuel Costs

The 2993cc diesel engine is on the larger side, so fuel won't be this car's strong point. Expect around 40 mpg in mixed driving, which works out to roughly £1,245 per year at current diesel prices of 148p per litre (based on 7,400 miles per year). Diesel cars of this age should have their DPF (diesel particulate filter) checked, as replacements can be costly.

What does it cost to own a 2009 BMW 5 SERIES?

Total estimated annual running cost is £1,900 (£158/month), broken down as £1245 fuel, £250 road tax, £55 MOT, and £350 predicted repairs. Repair costs are moderate, reflecting the 83% pass rate. Keeping on top of servicing will help avoid surprises.

BMW 5 SERIES Reliability Trend

Newer BMW 5 SERIESs show better MOT pass rates than older ones, with an average improvement of 11 percentage points.

Buying a Used 2009 BMW 5 SERIES

At 15 years old, the BMW 5 SERIES is firmly in budget territory. Purchase prices are low, but check for rust, worn suspension bushes, and electrical gremlins. A full service history is especially valuable at this age. If you're flexible on year, the 2023 model has the highest pass rate at 98%.

Alternatives to the 2009 BMW 5 SERIES

The BMW 5 SERIES is actually the most reliable option among similar diesel premium performances from this era. Here are comparable diesel cars with similar engines: