The biggest difference is the finance check. At MyCarCheck it comes with the £8.49 Comprehensive check; at CarCostCheck it is included in the £4.99 check, with the lender, agreement type, start date and term. That is £3.50 less for a check that includes finance.
The second difference is what the report does with the car's MOT record. CarCostCheck's free report turns it into a reliability score from 0 to 100, explains advisories and failures in plain English with estimated repair costs, estimates annual running costs (fuel, road tax, MOT and predicted repairs) and lists the common faults from the car's own MOT history. MyCarCheck does not list a reliability score or repair cost estimates.
To be fair to MyCarCheck, every one of its checks includes a valuation, while CarCostCheck's market valuation costs £2.99 (or £6.99 bundled with the history check). CarCostCheck's valuation adds the local dealer value where enough similar cars are listed near you, a days-to-sell estimate, a private sale price range, estimated remaining lifespan, and our estimated insurance group with example costs by driver age.
MyCarCheck is rated 4.5 out of 5 on Trustpilot from 293 reviews (checked 24 October 2026). Like CarCostCheck, it charges one-off prices with no subscription. As with any history check, a report is only as complete as the records behind it, so read it alongside the car's MOT history and check the V5C logbook against the car.
Try It Yourself
See what our free report shows. No sign-up, no email, instant results.
Enter a Reg Plate
At the same £4.99, CarCostCheck's check includes the outstanding finance check that MyCarCheck keeps for its £8.49 Comprehensive check, and the reliability score, repair cost estimates and running cost estimate come free. MyCarCheck includes a valuation, which costs £2.99 extra at CarCostCheck; even then, CarCostCheck's £6.99 bundle costs £1.50 less than MyCarCheck Comprehensive.
MyCarCheck is a well-rated service, and its Comprehensive check covers the essential safety checks with a valuation included. But its £4.99 Basic check leaves out outstanding finance, and adding it takes you to £8.49. If you want to know not just whether a car is safe to buy but whether it is a smart financial decision, CarCostCheck gives you the fuller picture: the finance check included for £4.99, plus a free reliability score, repair cost estimates and running costs.
Both services charge one-off prices with no subscription. The difference is what you get for £4.99: CarCostCheck adds the finance check and turns the car's MOT record into a reliability score, repair estimates and running costs, with problems flagged in plain English.
CarCostCheck is not just a cheaper alternative. As well as the history check, it helps you judge whether a car will be a good one to own. Here is what else you get, much of it before you pay anything:
- Market valuation from £2.99, based on live UK dealer listings. See the local dealer value for this car and how quickly similar cars sell near you.
- Estimated vehicle lifespan: An estimate of how many years the car has left on UK roads and the probability of it still being on the road in 12 months.
- Insurance costs by age: Estimated annual premiums for drivers aged 20, 30, 40, and 50.
- Running cost breakdown: Annual fuel, road tax, MOT, predicted repairs, and total cost per month for this specific car.
- Reliability score (0-100): one number based on the car's MOT record, including its pass rate, recent failures, advisory trend and mileage. Free.
- Common faults: the problems that keep coming up in the car's own MOT history. Free.
- 16 free checks: Full MOT history, mileage verification, reliability score, running costs, fuel costs, red flag alerts, common faults, recall check, ULEZ compliance, tax and MOT status, and more. All before you pay anything.
The premium check (£4.99) uses Experian AutoCheck data for the stolen, outstanding finance and write-off checks. The complete bundle (history + valuation) is £6.99.
Ready to Check a Car?
12 checks included free. Premium stolen, finance, and write-off checks for just £4.99. Market valuation from £2.99.
Check a Car Now