Electric cars are consistently more expensive to insure than equivalent petrol cars. The reasons are straightforward: battery replacement costs are extreme (£5,000 to £20,000+), specialist repair facilities are still limited, and repair times are longer because fewer mechanics are trained on EV systems.
| Car | Insurance Group | Typical Premium (30yr, 5yr NCB) |
| MG4 Standard Range | 18-22 | £550-£800 |
| Tesla Model 3 | 48-50 | £900-£1,400 |
| Nissan Leaf (40kWh) | 16-21 | £480-£700 |
| BMW i4 | 41-49 | £800-£1,300 |
| VW ID.3 | 22-28 | £550-£850 |
For comparison, a Ford Fiesta 1.0 EcoBoost sits in insurance groups 7 to 14 (typical premium £350 to £550 for the same driver). A Tesla Model 3 at group 48 to 50 costs roughly double to insure. This is a significant ongoing cost that narrows the fuel savings.
Look up a model's typical insurance group in our insurance groups guide. For a specific car, our £2.99 valuation includes our estimated insurance group with example quotes, and our free car check tool shows its running costs.
Since 1 April 2025, electric cars pay road tax. An EV first registered from 1 April 2017 pays the standard rate of £200 a year (a brand-new EV pays £10 for its first year). EVs registered between March 2001 and March 2017 pay the Band A rate of £20 a year. EVs registered from 1 April 2025 with a list price over £50,000 also pay the "expensive car supplement" of £440 a year for five years, starting from the second time the car is taxed, bringing the total to £640 a year. EVs registered before 1 April 2025 do not pay the supplement.
This is a significant change. If you are buying a used EV, factor in £200 a year for most cars registered since April 2017, or £640 a year for a newer EV that cost over £50,000.
Servicing and Maintenance
EVs have fewer moving parts than combustion engines: no oil changes, no spark plugs, no exhaust system, no clutch (in most cases), and no timing belt or chain. This translates to lower servicing costs:
| Item | EV Cost | Petrol Car Cost |
| Annual service | £80-£150 | £150-£300 |
| Brake pads (lifetime) | 100,000+ miles (regen braking) | 25,000-40,000 miles |
| Tyres | £100-£200 each (heavier cars = faster wear) | £60-£150 each |
| Coolant system | Battery cooling check at service | Flush every 3-5 years (£80-£120) |
| 12V battery | Replacement every 4-6 years (£80-£150) | Same |
EVs save roughly £200 to £400 per year on servicing and maintenance compared to petrol equivalents. However, tyre wear is faster on EVs due to their heavier weight and instant torque, which partially offsets the savings.
MOT: electric cars need an MOT on the same schedule as any other car, from three years old. In 2025, 13.4% of electric cars failed their first MOT at the first attempt, against 10.3% of petrol cars, and they still failed about 12% more often than petrol cars with the same mileage. See our electric car MOT failure rates study for every fuel type and electric model.
Here is a realistic annual running cost comparison for a typical mid-range car, assuming home charging for the EV:
| Cost Category | EV (e.g. MG4) | Petrol (e.g. Ford Focus 1.0) |
| Fuel / Charging | £350 (off-peak) | £1,400 |
| Insurance | £650 | £450 |
| Road Tax | £200 | £200 |
| Servicing | £120 | £250 |
| Tyres | £200 | £150 |
| Total | £1,520 | £2,450 |
On these numbers, the EV saves approximately £930 per year in running costs. Over 5 years, that is about £4,650. Whether this offsets the higher purchase price depends on the specific cars being compared and how depreciation plays out.
Depreciation is the largest single cost of car ownership, and it is where EVs have historically struggled. Battery technology evolves rapidly, and a 3-year-old EV with 200 miles of range looks less attractive when new models offer 300+ miles. However, the used EV market is maturing and depreciation curves are stabilising.
Tesla Model 3s hold their value better than most EVs (roughly 55% to 60% after 3 years). Budget EVs like the MG4 and BYD Atto 3 depreciate faster (roughly 45% to 50% after 3 years) because new prices keep falling. Premium EVs (BMW i4, Mercedes EQC) depreciate aggressively (40% to 45% after 3 years) because the technology ages quickly relative to new models.
An EV makes financial sense if:
- You can charge at home or work (ideally on a cheap overnight tariff)
- You drive 10,000+ miles per year (more miles = more fuel savings)
- You plan to keep the car for 3+ years (to offset the purchase premium)
- You do not need to make regular long journeys without reliable charging stops
An EV may NOT save you money if:
- You rely entirely on public rapid chargers
- You drive fewer than 6,000 miles per year (fuel savings are too small to offset higher insurance)
- You change cars every 1 to 2 years (depreciation may work against you)
- You are comparing against a very efficient petrol hybrid (e.g. Toyota Yaris Hybrid)
Whether you are considering electric, petrol, diesel, or hybrid, our free car check tool calculates personalised running costs for any registered UK vehicle. Enter the registration number to see the tax band, fuel costs, MOT history, and predicted annual running costs. It works for EVs, hybrids, and combustion cars, giving you a direct comparison in seconds.